vol 16, num 3 | October, 2019
 
 
committeeslogo
 
Bankruptcy Litigation
 
AN ABI COMMITTEE NEWSLETTER
 
Visit the Bankruptcy Litigation Committee page
 
 
 
► IN THIS ISSUE:
 
space-height
 
Ignoring the Labels: Oil and Gas Gathering Agreements as Executory Contracts
William C. Blasses
 
William C. Blasses
Kerr, Russell and Weber, PLC
Detroit
 
 
Although 11 U.S.C. § 365(a) allows for rejection of executory contracts, determining whether a contract is, in fact, executory can be challenging. As illustrated by a recent Second Circuit case, whether an oil and gas gathering agreement can be fully rejected as an executory contract depends on the state law governing the dispute and the relationship of the covenants to real property.

In an unpublished decision issued in May 2018, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals affirmed a bankruptcy court decision finding that certain oil and gas gathering agreements were not covenants that “run with the land” and therefore could be rejected as executory contracts. While the Second Circuit’s decision was premised on a finding of a lack of horizontal privity, that finding is of limited value given that the requirement is being abolished in a growing number of jurisdictions. The analysis afforded by the bankruptcy court and district court, however, suggest that elimination of the horizontal privity requirement would not necessarily change the result unless the covenants can be shown to have a beneficial impact on the land itself, not merely on the product derived from the land.

 
READ MORE
 
 
 
Oil and Gas Lease, or Farmout Agreement? Section 541(b)(4)(a)’s Exclusion of Farmout Agreements from Property of the Estate
Timothy J. Anzenberger
 
Timothy J. Anzenberger
Adams and Reese LLP
Ridgeland, Miss.
 
Alexander Bondurant
 
Alexander Bondurant
Adams and Reese LLP
Ridgeland, Miss.
 
 
Since 2015, bankruptcy courts have seen a steady flow of oil and gas bankruptcies — totaling around $106.8 billion in aggregate debt — with no slowdown in sight. These cases bring along the complex transactions common in the industry, governed by differing state laws and raising novel issues under the Bankruptcy Code. One such issue is the application of 11 U.S.C. § 541(b)(4)(A) to oil and gas agreements. That section excludes from property of the estate a debtor’s interest in oil and gas that has been transferred under a “farmout agreement.” But what constitutes a farmout varies according to state law and the agreement itself. Whether the interests underlying these agreements are property of the estate has important consequences in a bankruptcy case.

The quintessential oil and gas transaction is the lease. In its most basic form, a mineral owner conveys its right to explore, develop and produce oil and gas to an operating company in exchange for a royalty. A lease typically lasts for a primary term but will continue beyond the primary term if a producing well is drilled. If the operating company fails to drill a producing well by the end of the primary term, the lease terminates, and the interest reverts to the mineral owner. While termed a “lease,” the agreement typically conveys title of the subsurface rights to the lessee during the term. And so, in most states, the lease conveys a real property interest subject to divestiture.

 
READ MORE
 
 
 
Register Now for Winter Leadership Conference
Join the Bankruptcy Litigation Committee at ABI's Winter Leadership Conference. The Terranea Resort in Rancho Palos Verdes, California is the setting for this year's annual program, which features topics designed for consumer and business practitioners, as well as financial advisors. As always, the conference provides numerous social and fun events to network and renew friendships with your colleagues from around the nation and overseas. We look forward to seeing you in December!

This year, the Committee will be pairing with the Health Care Committee to host a session titled, “Litigating Issues in a Health Care Case."

Speakers for this session include:

  • Tania Moyron
    Dentons; Los Angeles
  • David Gordon
    Polsinelli; Atlanta
  • Andrew Sherman
    Sills Cummis & Gross P.C.; Newark, NJ
  • Margaret Newell
    Department of Justice Civil Division, Commercial Litigation Branch; Washington DC
 
REGISTER TODAY
 
 
 
 
Mid-Level Professional Development Program
 
 
 
Winter Leadership Conference
 
 
 
logo-footer
 
icon_circle-facebook icon_circle-twitter icon_circle-linkedin icon_circle-instagram
 
©2019 American Bankruptcy Institute . All rights reserved.
66 Canal Center Plaza, Suite 600, Alexandria, VA 22314